Is Florence Safe? An Honest Guide for American Travelers (2026)
Disclosure: Some links in this guide are affiliate links. If you book or buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — it helps keep our guides free.
- Florence is safe for most visitors; the US State Department rates Italy Level 2, Exercise Increased Caution.
- The realistic risk is a lifted phone: pickpocketing is the main crime tourists face, worst around the Duomo, trams and the station.
- Walk smart around the station, skip a rental car, and you will be fine.

Yes, Florence is safe for most visitors: the US State Department keeps Italy at Level 2 “Exercise Increased Caution” (last updated 23 May 2025), and the realistic risk here is a lifted phone, not violence. The catch is that Florence has a real petty-crime problem.
Il Sole 24 Ore’s 2025 crime index puts the province in Italy’s top three for reported crime, driven by pickpocketing in a compact center packed with tourists. Walk smart around the station, skip a rental car, and you will be fine.
| Risk | Reality | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Pickpocketing | The main crime tourists face; worst around the Duomo, trams and Santa Maria Novella station | Front pocket or zipped crossbody, phone off café tables |
| Violent crime | Rare against tourists in the historic center | Normal city awareness late at night |
| Station area at night | Designated a police “red zone” since October 2024 | Pass through, don’t linger; take a taxi after midnight |
| Petition and bracelet scams | Common in piazzas and at outdoor tables | Say “No, grazie” and keep walking |
| ZTL driving fines | Cameras ticket every unauthorized entry | Don’t drive into the center; park outside it |
The honest answer: safe, but pickpockets are busy
Florence is walkable and well lit, with police and soldiers posted at the big sights. What you will run into is opportunistic theft. Il Sole 24 Ore reported that 11,051 pickpocketing thefts (furti con destrezza) were reported in Florence in 2024, up 48% on the year before and the highest figure in its records since 2006.
The province logged roughly 6,500 crime reports per 100,000 residents, behind Milan and alongside Rome at the top of the national table.

The real picture: you are very unlikely to be hurt, and quite likely to be targeted if you leave a phone on a table. Still deciding? Our take on whether Florence is worth visiting covers the crowds and costs too.
Neighborhoods to avoid after dark
The Prefecture of Florence designated “zone rosse” (red zones) starting 10 October 2024 and renewed them in May 2026. These are areas where police can remove people with recent convictions who are behaving disruptively. In the center, they are:
– Santa Maria Novella station and its surrounding piazza – Via Palazzuolo, a narrow street a few blocks east of the station – Cascine park, the long riverside park west of the center
Between October 2024 and May 2026, police checked 39,399 people in these zones and issued 394 removal orders, according to La Nazione. Daytime is normal. After about 11 p.m., walk straight through the station area, and skip Cascine entirely at night. The stadium area and Novoli are also on the list, though few tourists go there.
Scams that actually happen in Florence
– The fake petition. Someone with a clipboard, often pretending to be deaf, asks you to sign for a charity, then demands a “donation.” Local press describes a variant at cafés: a card or trinket goes on your table, and your phone goes with it when they pick it up. – The friendship bracelet. A vendor ties a bracelet on your wrist, then wants cash.
La Nazione specifically flags Piazza Santa Maria Novella and Via Tornabuoni. – The stepped-on painting. Prints are laid on the ground near the Duomo and the Accademia; step on one and you are asked to pay. The fix for all of them: don’t stop, don’t sign, don’t accept anything placed in your hand.
Transport safety and the ZTL trap
The T2 tram links the airport to the Unità stop beside Santa Maria Novella in about 22 minutes; it gets crowded, so keep a hand on your bag. Licensed white taxis are safe; use the official rank, not someone approaching you in the terminal.
The bigger financial risk is driving. The historic center is a ZTL (limited traffic zone), active Monday to Friday 7:30 a.m.–8 p.m. and Saturday 7:30 a.m.–4 p.m., per the City of Florence, plus late nights in summer. Cameras photograph plates, and fines arrive by mail months later.
Published figures range from USD 90–377 (EUR 80–335) per entry, and rental companies typically add USD 34–56 (EUR 30–50) per ticket in admin fees (converted at USD 1 = EUR 0.89). Two loops around the block can mean two fines.
If you want Tuscany by car, pick it up on the way out of town; our day trips from Florence guide shows which towns are easier by train anyway.
Solo and female travel
Florence is one of the easier Italian cities to do alone. The center is small, and streets around the Duomo, Piazza della Signoria and Santa Croce stay busy into the evening. Expect some catcalling, annoying rather than dangerous.
Watch your drink in student-heavy bars and book lodging in the Oltrarno or Santa Croce rather than on Via Palazzuolo. A tight Florence itinerary that groups sights by area keeps late-night walking short.
Who should think twice about Florence
Florence is not ideal if you hate crowds, because crowds are exactly what pickpockets work, and July in the center can feel overwhelming. Travelers with limited mobility should know the sidewalks are narrow and uneven. Our guide to the best time to visit Florence explains why late fall and early spring feel calmer. Choosing between cities? See Florence vs Venice.
What to do in an emergency
Dial 112, Italy’s single emergency number for police, ambulance and fire. To report a theft for insurance, go to a Carabinieri station: one is at Piazza della Stazione 7 (8 a.m. to 10 p.m.), others near the Uffizi and at Piazza Pitti. For a stolen passport, the US Consulate General is at Lungarno Vespucci 38 (+39 055 266 951). Travel insurance that covers theft is worth having here.
Where to stay
– Oltrarno (Santo Spirito, San Frediano): across the river, quieter at night and full of good local restaurants. Best for couples and repeat visitors. – Santa Croce: central, lively in the evening, and a short walk to everything. Good for first-timers and solo travelers. – Around San Marco and the Duomo: you trade some noise for being steps from the big sights. Good for short stays and families.

Compare options in our list of the best hotels in Florence, then check live prices below.
Find your Florence hotel on the map
Live prices from Booking, Airbnb and more — move the map or change dates to compare stays across Florence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it safe to walk around Florence at night?
Yes, in the historic center, where streets around the Duomo, Santa Croce and the Oltrarno stay lit and busy late. The exceptions are the Santa Maria Novella station area, Via Palazzuolo and Cascine park, which police have designated red zones. Pass through the station quickly after dark and avoid Cascine at night.
Are there parts of Florence to avoid?
Not many. Police single out Santa Maria Novella station, Via Palazzuolo and Cascine park in the center, plus Novoli and the stadium area further out. None are off-limits by day, but they are not places to linger late at night or to book a cheap room without reading recent reviews.
Is Florence safe for American tourists?
Yes. The US State Department rates Italy at Level 2 (updated 23 May 2025), citing terrorism risk, not anything specific to Florence. Americans are mostly targeted by pickpockets because they are easy to spot in crowds. Use a zipped bag and keep your phone off tables to remove most of the risk.
Which is safer, Florence or Rome?
They are similar. In Il Sole 24 Ore’s 2025 index, both provinces sit in Italy’s top three for reported crime at about 6,400 to 6,500 reports per 100,000 residents, and both problems are mostly theft. Florence’s center is smaller and easier to navigate at night, which many travelers find more relaxed.
What should I do if I get pickpocketed in Florence?
Cancel your cards first, then file a report at a Carabinieri station, such as Piazza della Stazione 7 near Santa Maria Novella; insurers will ask for it. If your passport was taken, contact the US Consulate General on Lungarno Vespucci for an emergency replacement.
Planning the whole trip? Start with our Florence travel guide for the overview, then use this page for the details.





